news
home about me news to the collection

27-02-2010

Laphroaig founded by Irish?

During the last couple of years I received several questions from members of the Johnston family and Gaelic scholars why Laphroaig's version on their website of the earliest history is different than the one in "The Legend of Laphroaig" and which is commonly accepted by historians. A lot of incorrect information has been published about their history and this has always been a sensitive point to the Johnston descendants. Therefore I have added a small chapter to "history" about it. Come on Laphroaig, please change it! It's nonsense. Laphroaig is not of Irish origin!

Recent DNA tests clearly indicate that the Johnstons are decsendants from Clan Donald.

You can find the DNA results here: http://dna-project.clan-donald-usa.org/DNAmain.htm

"On Laphroaig’s official website it is stated that the Johnstons were descendants from three McCabe brothers (being of MacDonald stock) who came to Islay after the Jacobite uprising of 1745. Historically this is not true. There are no records of McCabes on Islay in the 18th century and the direct ancestors of the Johnston family can be tracked down till around 1715. (The McCabes are an Irish clan, branch of the MacLeods of Arran who immigrated to Ireland in the 14th century.)
Except for the McCabe part, the story of three brothers coming to Islay comes from an interview in a Canadian newspaper The Scottish Canadian in 1912 with John Johnson, great grandfather of Canadian Johnston descendant, Finlay Johnson Payne. John Johnson's version of the Clan history was entirely based on the Oral (Gaelic) Tradition.
Finlay gave a copy of the article to Bessie Williamson in 1959, who left it in the Laphroaig files, where subsequent writers unfortunately have used it. He and other family members went on researching and found out his great grandfather’s re-telling of the earlier Clan history wasn´t completely accurate.
Of course there might have been three Johnston (MacIain) brothers coming to Islay at the same time, after all they were a truly clannish family and their fortunes paralleled and intersected, but the Johnstons mentioned in the article, Ronald, Duncan and Alexander, were NO brothers."

 

Clan map by Laphroaig, probably from the late 1970-ties. The MacIans of Clan Donald from Ardnamurchan are generally considered to be the ancestors of the founders Donald and Alexander Johnston. Hmm, no McCabes on the (Laphroaig) map...

21-02-2010

Diego Sandrin is a famous Italian singer/songwriter and perhaps more important (..) whisky aficionado.


(interview on Whiskyfun.com in August 2006)

Diego has a talent for experimenting with wood finishes. Italian style of course. These are his latest two expressions:

10 year old cask strength finished in a Raboso cask

10 year old cask strength finished in a Fragolino cask

Especially the Raboso is asthonishing. I am no big fan of exotic wood finishes, but this is very, very good.
Just 22 bottles filled, so try and get your hands on a bottle fast!
(many thanks Diego, well done!)

12-01-2010

It's website season...here's another great new website by my whisky buddies Hans Dillesse and Govert van Bodegom: www.longmornbrothers.com

Longmorn is one of my absolute favorites. And these guys together hold the largest collection in the world. And even better, don't mind cracking a bottle or two open now and then.
This pic is one of the finest expressions ever. An 18 year old distilled in 1971 by Marchesi Spinola.


09-01-2010

Great new website about Islay whiskies : www.whiskyfromislay.com

Join and let's get this started!!

27-11-2009

Difficult to find new and interesting Laphroaigs, but here are two excellent bottles by Douglas Laing:

20 year old Platinum Selection from 1989

21 year old old Malt Cask from 1987

12-10-2009

WARNING , SPRINGBANK COLLECTION STOLEN!

Sad news, our friend Michiel Wigman, who's not only the biggest Springbank collector in the world but also very knowledgeable and always ready to help, just found out that a part of his collection was stolen (exactly 183 bottles that were in a storage house, not at his home).
No need to say that Michiel is devastated, so please let's try to help him by keeping an eye open on any suspect auction or other kind of sale that would include one or several Springbanks or Longrows that are listed here:
(Excel list). Should you notice anything, please just drop me a line .Thank you!
Please note that the remaining part of Michiel's collection is neither in that storage house, nor at his home anymore.

 

20-09-2009

Excellent Dutch website, where you can order whisky kits containing six tubes of 25 ml single malt or old and rare blended whisky: www.rarewhiskysite.com . Try the blends! Some are as old as the early 1900's and exquisite. Highly recommended. These old blends are much better than many of today's single malts.

 

05-09-2009

This bottle was sent to me as a gift by the Whisky Trader (Germany):

7 year old private bottling from 2001 (thanks Wolfgang)

New added: rare jug by Riverside Works (England), probably from the 1970-ties


22-08-2009

Somewhere in the 1990-ties the idea arose that Laphroaig was founded in 1815, which was from a PR point of view understandable. It is likely however (illicit) distilling had been going on since the 1790-ties, maybe even earlier, when Alexander Johnston, father of the supposed founders Donald and Alexander, leased some land at Torradale, now Laphroaig. It was very usual for farmers to distil as a way to make some extra money or just for their personal use. Islay being a remote island, the Ileach didn't bother too much about regulations imposed upon them by London. It isn't until 1826 that Donald is recorded for the first time in the Excise accounts as "licensed distiller". I don't think there was an actual "founding date". It just gradually started, combined with farming which ended in the 1960-ties. Likewise Laphroaig was probably founded by the Johnston family, not just by Donald and Alexander. In 1815 Donald was 19 years old and Alex only 12 years. A bit young, unless they had their family looking over their shoulders. The whole thing just became more serious somewhere around 1820.

  In April 1815 the largest eruption in historic time occurred, when the Tambora volcano erupted in Indonesia. Clouds of dust blurring the sun world wide, causing global climate anomalies with extremely cold weather in Scotland and Ireland. Agricultural crops failed and livestock died, causing the worst famine of the 19th century. Thousands of people perished because of starvation and the succesive outbreak of typhus. This must have affected Islay's distilleries severely too. It is unlikely grains would have been used for distilling. This lasted almost three years, 1816 being an extremely cold year with frost until June and became known as "The Year Without Summer". With barley being harvested in August, Laphroaig probably didn't distil much in 1815.


Farming at Laphroaig in 1904

21-08-2009

Another collector's nightmare, similar to batches: different casks at Highgrove: Highgrove 2009 cask 135

17-08-2009

Never seen this (50cl?) bottle before. Given the statement "Old Liqueur Scotch Whisky", it seems to be from the 1930-ties or 1940-ties. I discovered the picture on the Glasgow University. Don't think, I will ever find this one...


14-08-2009

Added: 1994 and 1998 High Spirits

Rare 15 year old US import by Hiram Walker (thanks Bryan)

Beautiful 21 year old Laphroaig to commemorate Douglas Laing's 60th Anniversary. Though it's from a single cask, no year of distillation or bottling given.

10-08-2009

 

The graves of Laphroaig founders Donald (left) and Alexander (right). Donald died in 1847 and is buried with his first wife Isabella McDougall and young son Alex (age 5) at Kilnaughton Cemetery, Port Ellen. Their grave lies East of the old chapel. His second wife Alice McDougall died in Canada. His younger brother Alex emigrated to Australia and died in 1881. He is buried with his wife Flora McTaggert at Sandgate Cemetry, Newcastle, Australia (picture courtesy of Lin Johnston, great-great granddaughter of Alex). Is there a connection with the "Ardbeg" McDougalls..?



The old chapel at Kilnaughton Cemetry, Port Ellen

03-08-2009

John McDougall has confirmed there were indeed two wash stills and three small spirit stills when he arrived at Laphroaig to become manager in 1970.
John just started a really nice website with a whisky forum. He knows a lot about making whisky and you can discuss matters with him here.

18-07-2009

It has always been generally assumed when Laphroaig was sold to Seager Evans Group (Long John Int.) in 1967, the distillery expanded its capacity from 4 to 6 stills. The old still house which contained 4 stills ever since 1924, became the new boiler house and the stills moved across the site to a new still house. I was going through some of my old files and found a press release by Seager Evans dated 30th of May 1967 which says:

“The work is carried out in stages, and the New Still House is now operating-the Old Spirit Stills having been transferred to a new site, and an identical still is added to the range. The New Wash Stills are copies of the old ones, with New Safes, and Condensers taking the place of the Old Worm Tubs.”

It was accompanied by these pictures (thanks Iain Russell):

 

On the pictures you clearly see 5 stills, not 6. The accompanying text also indicates there were 5 stills.
Why would official press release photographs show 5 stills if there were 6??

This is an extract from Gavin Smith and John McDougall's excellent book "Wort, Worms & Wash backs (1999). John McDougall was manager at Laphroaig from 1970 -1974. It's on page 85: 

“Increasing the number of wash stills (in 1972) was comparatively simple, because there were already two, and the installation of one extra wash still could take care of the extra capacity required. When it came to the spirit stills, however, two new ones were needed, but on grounds of cost-effectiveness it was decided that one double-sized still would be installed.”

Then there is this old drawing from the early 1970-ties for an extension to eight stills:


(click twice on the image)

If you look closely, you see the proposed extensions which confirms there were actually 5 stills.

This is what I think has happened: Hume & Moss mistakenly recorded 6 stills in their book “The Making of Scotch Whisky” in 1981, and subsequent writers have copied this. As a result the expansion to 6 stills is recorded in almost every whisky book. Among them Hans and myself in "The Legend of Laphroaig"...

There were never 6 stills and the capacity went from 4 to 5 in 1967 and from 5 to 7 in 1972.

12-07-2009

A collector's nightmare: batches..
First issued at Feis Ile 2009 at the distillery.
Guess I will leave it with this first batch...
New added: First batch of the 10 year old cask strength

Also added the one that got away: 10 year old with tube and slightly different font.
The label was a try-out by the visitor centre for the customized labels. It had nothing to do with the Milan Whisky Festival and wasn't supposed to leave the distillery, but it did. Only customized bottle with tube.

In case this upsets some people: hey guys, it's just a bottle of whisky!
(thank you, Geert)

Here's the link again to the interview with Iain Henderson.

FAKE ALERT!!

06-07-2009

Busy times in fake bottles wonderland. Don't these people have decent holidays like everyone else?
This was sold on eBay by "ltr1967" for £133 yesterday:

 
"A rare pre-release folder for laphroaig 1960 (limited to 300 bottles), dated 30th july 2001. the green folder contains the following : 1 x page of tasting notes. 1 x 3 pages tittled - Laphroaig unveils a truly definitive islay malt. 1 x 1 page titled - Laphroaig 1960 vintage reserve-defined by its long sleep by the sea 1 x 1 page titled - distillery managers - ensuring quality over generations 1 x 1 A4 colour image of the bottle and box. (on thin card) 1 x 1 A4 copy of certificate (thats included in the box) 1 x 1 A3 full colour folded sheet with info printed on both sides including the price of £375 per bottle and £199 for the 30yr old etc. multiple unused bottle and box lables - self adhesive on strips ( over 50 labels). Thanks for looking."

Shall we bet there will be 1960's Oddbins for sale on eBay shortly?

04-07-2009

Stunning new website by a fan of one the neighbours: www.ardbegproject.com

Two beautiful, new bottles by Douglas Laing:

20 year old sherry wood matured

21 year old Platinum Selection for Japan

Cairdeas Feis Ile 2009

FAKE ALERT!!

30-06-2009

If there is a "Fake Award of the Year", this is a serious contender for 2009.
I bought this from a guy on eBay. "Very Rare LAPHROAIG 15 yo ISLAY MALT Sealed Ceramic jug".
Spot the differences? OK, here we go.

A B



C



Left the "Hiram Walker" jug, right the common 12 year old Italian import by Bonfanti (pics A and B). Different color, size? Not impossible. Left jug just a back label, right jug back label and words embossed (pics A and B). Correct statement for the 1970-ties and early 1980-ties: "Islay Malt Scotch Whisky". On the US label: "75cl and 43%". For the US in that period "750ml, 4/5 quart or 25.5 fl. ozs. and 86 US proof" was usual. The "5" font on the label is not one ever used by Laphroaig.
Pic C: US tax seal "Imported by Hiram Walker, Michigan." A look at the bottom of both jugs: pic D. Left jug (Hiram Walker) with logo "DSS" (pic E), obvious joint on the left jug, right jug bottom blank. A little search on Google produces a DSS ceramic manufacturer in Thailand. The usual supplier for nearly all stoneware however was Govancroft Potteries in Glasgow till the 1980-ties and Wade for high value issues. A close look at the seal (pic F and G) and label (pic H) of the US jug show a grainy print, obviously home made with an ordinairy printer. Compare this with pics I and J with a razor sharp, professional print. Crucial however is Hiram Walker never imported Laphroaig till the 1990-ties, when it became part of Allied Domecq. Its name only on Canadian Club and a few liqueurs before.

Despite the fact seller has an impressive feedback record, I found out he was involved in two other cases of dodgy bottles. To his defence I have to say he immediately offered a full refund. As a collector you are sometimes just too eager. Do ask questions, be critical, ask advice from experts. Check sellers who buy empty bottles, labels, presentation tins and boxes etc. And better use PayPal for payment.
That way you may have a chance of regaining your money. If I just had googled Hiram Walker, I might have known. Because, no matter how brilliant the fake, there is always something that's not right or doesn't feel right.
As for me, I will be more humble about my own expertise...



D




E

    F G


H





I





J


23-06-2009

It was in 1994 that my wife and I entered the small visitor centre of Laphroaig for the first time. There was no one there and we looked a bit around, till a gentleman showed up with a green "Laphroaig" embroidered sweater. He introduced himself: "Hi, I am Iain Henderson, I am the manager". There wasn't a tour anymore that day, but he showed us around as if we were the first tourists he saw that year. When we left we bought a nice bottle. A 30 year old Ardbeg...sorry for that. I have met Iain on a number of occasions. Last time we met was at the launch of "The Legend of Laphroaig" November 2007 when he had come over to Holland for the occasion, hosted by Dutch Laphroaig importer A Brand New Day.

We were in Scotland the last week of May this year and had made an appointment with Iain to meet and have lunch in St. Andrews. He had agreed on doing an interview for WhiskyFun.com. Serge Valentin and I had prepared some questions and the result you can see here: www.whiskyfun.com. Thanks for the interview, Iain. The next months I will show some of Iains private pictures which he kindly has given me to scan.


14-06-2009

It's getting harder and harder finding new and interesting bottles, but soon expected: batch no.1 of the 10 year old cask strength and the Feis Ile 2009 bottle. I will also add pictures from time to time from the personal collection of former manager Iain Henderson. Here are two, reflecting how moody Islay weather can be.


01-05-2009

New added two G&M "brown labels":

Laphroaig 1968 (thanks to Hans-Jürgen Frisch)

Laphroaig 1973

and a Samaroli 1984 (thanks Diego Sandrin and Max Righi)

pack of 3 x 33.3 cl distillery bottles

replacing Laphroaig's 15 year old: 18 year old

first Islay Mist without statement "D. Johnston & Co (Laphroaig)":

Islay Mist by MacDuff

10-04-2009

No news, just a nice pic, and another one by Hans Dillesse:




08-04-2009

New home page. To see another picture press F5.

05-04-2009

Ended my Face Book profile today. Time consuming and highly susceptible for privacy abuse. Real friends know how to find you.

28-03-2009

Very happy with this 27 year old bottle for the staff members of Laphroaig. Only 94 bottles. Comes with certificate:



(Billy and Alex, thanks guys!)

New added: Highgrove 2008 edition

27-03-2009

Nice new Dutch website: The Whisky Sites Directory

20-03-2009

Jack Wiebers has a keen eye for great presentations:

18 year old "The Old Train Line"

28-02-2009

Found this postcard probably from the late 1970-ties. The old chimney, which was knocked down around 1983 is still erect.

27-02-2009

New added: an experiment by my Italian friend Diego Sandrin, who finished a 10 year old cask strength distillery bottle in a Clinto cask for 14 months. I am not a big fan of exotic wood finishes but this is really good. Read Whiskyfun.com's comment about this bottle.

I have been looking for this strange mini for the Japanese market for years:

combination of a Laphroaig and Glenfiddich mini

Through a  marketing tie up ALLIED SUNTORY distributed both brands in Japan.
For a spell the Glenfiddich manager  and Iain Henderson were on big billboards in Japan and
were treated like pop stars...

16-01-2009

New added: Triple wood

10 year old distillery bottle with customised label

21 year old distillery bottle for the US market (thanks Andy)

10 year old distillery mini

Laphroaig's origin Irish?

During the last year I have received several questions from the Johnston family and Gaelic researchers why Laphroaig's version on their website of the earliest history is different than the one in "The Legend of Laphroaig" and which is commonly accepted by historians. A lot of incorrect information has been written about their history in the past and this has always been a sensitive point to the Johnston family. Therefore I have added a small chapter to "history" about it. Come on Laphroaig, please change it! Laphroaig is not of Irish origin!

"On Laphroaig’s official website it is stated that the Johnstons were descendants from three McCabe brothers (being of MacDonald stock) who came to Islay after the Jacobite uprising of 1745. Historically this is not true. There are no records of McCabes on Islay in the 18th century and the direct ancestors of the Johnston family can be tracked down till around 1715. (The McCabes are an Irish clan, branch of the MacLeods of Arran who immigrated to Ireland in the 14th century.)
Except for the McCabe part, the story of three brothers coming to Islay comes from an interview in a Canadian newspaper The Scottish Canadian in 1912 with John Johnson, great grandfather of Canadian Johnston descendant, Finlay Johnson Payne. John Johnson's version of the Clan history was entirely based on the Oral (Gaelic) Tradition.
Finlay gave a copy of the article to Bessie Williamson in 1959, who left it in the Laphroaig files, where subsequent writers unfortunately have used it. He and other family members went on researching and found out his great grandfather’s re-telling of the earlier Clan history wasn´t completely accurate.
Of course there might have been three Johnston (MacIain) brothers coming to Islay at the same time, after all they were a truly clannish family and their fortunes paralleled and intersected, but the Johnstons mentioned in the article, Ronald, Duncan and Alexander, were NO brothers."

 

Archives 2008
Archives 2007
Archives 2006
Archives 2005